14 Edna Mahan Corrections Officers Indicted on Conspiracy, Misconduct Charges

A state grand jury voted on September 27, 2022, to indict 14 corrections officers who were charged after a January 2021 incident at the Hunterdon County-based Edna Mahan Correctional Facility for Women, in which inmates were forcibly removed from cells and some were beaten, leaving two of the victims severely injured.

Grand jurors returned an indictment against all 14 of the accused corrections officers on charges of conspiracy, official misconduct, tampering with public records, and aggravated assault.

The following defendants were indicted today by the grand jury:

• Sean St. Paul, 56, of Newark
• Ryan Valentin, 44, of Bloomfield
• Eddie Molina, 44, of East Brunswick
• Amir E. Bethea, 37, of Springfield
• Andraia Bridges, 45, of North Plainfield
• Anthony J. Valvano, 40, of Bound Brook
• Brandon Burgos, 22, of Roseland
• Luis A. Garcia, 25, of Nutley
• Courey James, 33, of East Piscataway
• Jose Irizarry, 38, of Paterson
• Desiree Lewis, 33, of Elizabeth
• Gustavo Sarmiento, 29, of Maywood
• Marika Sprow, 33, of West Orange
• Tara Wallace, 37, of Somerset

Investigators say the incidents happened during the overnight hours between January 11 and January 12, 2021, at the facility in Union Township, in Hunterdon County, amid escalating tensions after several incidents of inmates squirting unknown liquids through their cell doors, and striking officers.

Cells belonging to inmates suspected of being involved in those “splashing” incidents were targeted, through what the NJ Department of Corrections refers to as inmate extraction.

According to DOC policy, extraction should be resorted to only after inmates refuse orders to put on handcuffs and leave their cells on their own, or if they pose a threat to themselves or others and refuse to exit a cell.

In this case, prosecutors say, the officers planned to go into the cells and use force regardless of whether any resistance was encountered, and in some instances did not give the targeted inmates an opportunity to comply with orders to put on handcuffs and exit their cells without incident.

In other incidents, the inmates complied with orders to be handcuffed and yet were extracted by force from their cells anyway.

One inmate was punched almost 30 times by one officer while being extracted by a five-person team, despite no apparent provocation or physical resistance from her, the investigation found.

Other officers restrained the victim while the assault was happening, at times grabbing her hair or shoving her. She was taken to a hospital suffering from headaches, nausea, and vomiting, and doctors found she had a concussion.

Another victim, after her extraction, and despite the fact that she had complied with orders to be handcuffed, was covered with blood and her right eye was swollen shut. She was transported to Hunterdon Medical Center where doctors discovered her skull was broken around her eye. Boot marks were also discovered on her body.

The indictment alleges these officers planned, supervised, participated in, or failed to stop “one or more forced cell extractions on the Restorative Housing Unit tier with the purpose of punishing, intimidating, or terrorizing one or more inmates.”

They are also accused of facilitating, failing to intervene in, and failing to report the assaults, as is their duty as law enforcement officers.

Investigators allege that internal reports generated about the incidents were false or misleading in an attempt to conceal the officers’ brutality and the events leading to the attacks.

The conspiracy charge carries a sentence of five to 10 years in state prison and a fine of $150,000; Official Misconduct can carry a penalty of five to 10 years in state prison with five years parole ineligibility, and a fine of $150,000, while tampering with public records is punishable by three to five years in state prison with two years parole ineligibility and a fine of $15,000.

Aggravated assault with a serious bodily injury can carry a sentence of five to 10 years in state prison, with a mandate to serve 85 percent of the sentence, plus a fine of $150,000.

The charges are merely accusations, and the defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in a court of law.

Defense counsel -

For Sean St. Paul: Ronald J. Ricci, Esq.
For Ryan Valentin: Timothy M. Donohue, Esq.
For Eddie Molina: Steven D. Altman, Esq.
For Amir E. Bethea: Peter R. Willis, Esq.
For Andraia Bridges: James V. Pomaco, Esq.
For Anthony J. Valvano: Jeffrey Garrigan, Esq.
For Brandon Burgos: Anthony J. Iacullo, Esq.
For Luis A. Garcia: Robert R. Cannan, Esq.
For Courey James: Mike Pedicini, Esq.
For Jose Irizarry: Peter W. Till, Esq.
For Desiree Lewis: Michael P. Rubas, Esq.
For Gustavo Sarmiento: Tamra D. Katcher, Esq.
For Marika Sprow: Matthew Troiano, Esq.
For Tara Wallace: Sharon Bittner-Kean, Esq.

For updates, subscribe to our free newsletter!

Morristown Minute has been approved for the 2022 Local News Fund!*

Our reporters will be dedicating time and resources to investigating the roadblocks to mental health accessibility in our town.

Donate to Morristown, NJs local mental health accessibility fund today!

Scan or click to donate!

*The 2022 Local News Fund is a program administered by the Local Media Foundation, a 501(c)(3) organization affiliated with the Local Media Association. The program's purpose is to allow independent and family-owned news organizations to solicit tax-deductible donations from their communities for journalism projects that focus on critical local issues. Contributions to this program are tax-deductible to the full extent of U.S. law; please consult a tax advisor for details.